Hillary Clinton won the popular vote in the 2016 Presidential Election by at least 2.8 million votes. She actually won the election but lost the Electoral College Vote: Clinton had 232 Electoral votes to Trump’s 306. On the basis of a true Democratic Vote, rule by the will of the majority of people in the country, Hillary Clinton actually got the majority of votes. She should have won the election.
Donald Trump won the actual election because of a system inaugurated by the Founding Fathers in the late 18th Century that allowed the election to be skewered toward the much less populated states. The initial issue in the late seventeen hundreds was representation for all thirteen states regardless of population.
Each state regardless of size got two senators while the number of representatives in the House of Representatives was determined by the population of each state. The smaller states didn’t want to be totally overshadowed then by the larger states. The 2016 Presidential Election is the fourth time in the history of the nation that the election has gone to the person with the lesser amount of the public votes.
It has happened twice in the 19th Century and, so far, twice in the 21st Century. As a rule the Republicans tend to do better in midterm election than in Presidential elections. This is mainly because a lot of voters don’t vote then. In addition to this Republicans use what methods they can to suppress the minority vote. Texas has been quite successful with voter suppression.
The majority political party in the United States is the Democratic Party, then comes the Republicans, then the Independents, down the line there are the Libertarians, and finally the Green Party. There are other groups but they tend to be regional. Occasionally there will be Third Party candidates.
During a Presidential Election only two of the fifty states, Nebraska and Maine, do not follow the winner take all principle. In the remaining forty-eight states whoever wins the majority of votes gets all the electoral votes for that state.
There are 435 elected members in the House of Representatives that represent the 50 states. There are three more that represent territories held by the United States. Not all territories are represented. The 435 seats is a fixed number. Every ten years a census is taken and the seats are redistributed based upon population changes. Regardless of population every state will have at least one member in the House. In the Senate every state is represented by two Senators regardless of population.
Every four years a Presidential Election is held. The voters, within the country, do not vote directly for the president. Instead they elect an invisible elector who will vote for the person they choose. There are 538 people who are chosen as electors, three or more from every state representing the members of Congress and three representing the U.S. territories. It takes 270 electoral votes to become President.
One of the problems with this system is that the Electoral Districts are the same as the House of Representative Districts. Both political parties, but the Republicans particularly, have gerrymandered their Districts within their states to give them the most advantage when it comes to elections. They have drawn the districts to break up Democratic blocks of voters and whenever possible give Republicans the advantage. This same advantage exists in the Electoral Districts of many states, since both are the same.
This advantage has allowed the Republicans to hold a majority in the House of Representatives since 2011 even though in 2012 over one and a quarter million more Democrats voted for members of the House. That same advantage existed for Donald J. Trump even though Hillary Clinton has received well over two million more votes from the general population than Donald Trump has gotten.
Two of the Texas electors have announced that they cannot in good conscious vote for Trump. One has stated that he will resign and the other will vote for another Republican. This, of course, will not change anything.
Since the overall population of the United States increases and continually relocates a National census is taken every ten years to determine the number of House of Representative Districts in the nation. The number is fixed at 435. The Congressional Election Districts are rearranged every ten years. Also within the cities of each state there is a continual movement from the rural areas to the urban cemters where most job opportunities occur, so that the population will dynamically change within the ten year period. Consequently the cities continue to grow making for totally unequal numbers in many of the Congressional Districts. Within most states the urban votes count for less each year against the rural districts, which tend to lose people continually.
What is true for the individual states is also true for the United States, except that here it works on a larger scale. The number of people voting in the larger states, which have many more and much larger urban areas, have their individual votes count for a lot less than those residing in the smaller states, particularly in the rural sections of the smaller states.
All fifty states are shown on MSNBC, CNN, or Fox News as either red or blue states: red is Republican and blue is Democratic. There are also purple states, which are the swing states that can go either way. Most of the campaigning during Presidential Elections is done in the purple or swing states.
These battleground states carry disproportionate influence in Presidential Elections. In 2016 most of the campaigning was done in just twelve states.
According to the U.S. Census Bureau there is a net population gain of one person every 13 seconds. This means that the United States gains 110.77 people every day or 40,431 every single year.
The following population statistics are taken from the Census Bureau’s July 2014 estimate. If anything they tend to be conservative.
The statistics here used were done by the Census Bureau in July of 2014. According to the official 2010 population count officially done by the Census Bureau the population of the United States was 308,745,538 and was estimated to be 318,857,056 in July of 2014. The 2016 Vote was taken from the results of the Presidential Election.
House Elect. Pop. Per |2016
Rank| State | Population| Seats| Votes |House Seat| V0te
1 | California | 38,802.500| 53 | 55 | 717,763| D
2 | Texas | 26,956,958| 36 | 38 | 734,867| R
3 | Florida | 19,893,297| 27 | 29 | 715,465| R
4 | New York | 19,746,227| 27 | 29 | 724,824| D
5 | Illinois | 12,880,580| 18 | 20 | 715.292 | D
6 |Pennsylvania | 12,787,209| 18 | 20 | 709,085 | R
7 | Ohio | 11,594163| 16 | 18 | 721,514 | R
8 | Georgia | 10,097,343| 14 | 16 | 708,568 | R
9 | N. Carolina | 9,943,964| 13 | 15 | 750,159| R
10 | Michigan | 9,909,877| 14 | 16 | 705,954| D
11 | New Jersey | 8,938,175| 12 | 14 | 738,716| D
12 | Virginia | 8,326,289| 11 | 13 | 744,170| D
13 |Washington | 7,061,530| 10 | 12 | 689,701| D
14 |Massachusetts| 6,745,408| 9 | 11 | 738,460| D
15 | Arizona | 6,731,484| 9 | 11 | 728,139| R
16 | Indiana | 6,596,855| 9 | 11 | 726,370| R
17 | Tennessee | 6,549,352| 9 | 11 | 717,360| R
18 | Missouri | 6,063,589 | 8 | 10 | 752,749| R
19 | Maryland | 5,976,407 | 8 | 10 | 735,570| D
20 | Wisconsin | 5,757,564 | 8 | 10 | 715,800| R
21 | Minnesota | 5,457,173 | 8 | 10 | 672,392| D
22 | Colorado | 5,355,856 | 7 | 9 | 741,083| D
23 | Alabama | 4,849,377 | 7 | 9 | 688,860| R
24 | S. Carolina | 4,832,482 | 7 | 9 | 674,818 | R
25 | Louisiana | 4,649.676 | 6 | 8 | 766,982 | R
26 | Kentucky | 4,413,457 | 6 | 8 | 730,069 | R
27 | Oregon | 3,970,239 | 5 | 7 | 779,871 | D
28 |Oklahoma | 3,878,051 | 5 | 7 | 762,964 | R
29 |Connecticut | 3,596,677 | 5 | 7 | 718,059 | D
30 | Iowa | 3,107,126 | 4 | 6 | 758,547 | R
31 | Arkansas | 2,994,079 | 4 | 6 | 737,283 | R
32 |Mississippi | 2,984,926 | 4 | 6 | 746,232 | R
33 | Utah | 2,942902 | 4 | 6 | 713,822 | R
34 | Kansas | 2,904,021 | 4 | 6 | 721,476 | R
35 | Nevada | 2,839,099 | 4 | 6 | 689,733 | D
36 |New Mexico | 2,085,572 | 3 | 5 | 695,179 | D
37 | Nebraska | 1,881,503 | 3 | 5 | 618,508 | R
38 | W. Virginia | 1,850,326 | 3 | 5 | 618,471 | R
39 | Idaho | 1,634,464| 2 | 4 | 797,864 | R
40 | Hawaii | 1,419,561| 2 | 4 | 696,157 | D
41 | Maine | 1,330,089 | 2 | 4 | 664,596 | D
42 | N. Hampshire| 1,326,813 | 2 | 4 | 660,350| D
43 |Rhode Island| 1,055,173 | 2 | 4 | 525,146| D
44 | Montana | 1,023,579 | 1 | 3 | 1,005,141| R
45 | Delaware | 935,614 | 1 | 3 | 917,029| D
46 | S. Dakota | 853,175 | 1 | 3 | 833,354| R
47 | N. Dakota | 739,482 | 1 | 3 | 699,628| R
48 | Alaska | 737,732 | 1 | 3 | 736,732| R
49 | Vermont | 626,011 | 1 | 3 | 626,562 | D
50 | Wyoming | 584,153 | 1 | 3 | 576,412 | R
Depending upon population every state has at least three people in Congress, two in the Senate and at least one in the House of Representatives. Wyoming, population-wise has the smallest population, a little over ½ million, while California has the largest population, almost 40 million. California has 53 house members and two Senators. The other states generally come between these two.
Altogether there are seven states that have only one representative in the House and two in the Senate. Of these two voted Democratic and five voted Republican. Only thirteen states have ten or more electoral votes. All the others go from one to nine.
If we take the bottom 29 states and count their total population then we have approximately the same population as California. They have 55 House Districts and 42 Senators. This gives them 97 electoral votes against California’s 55 electoral votes. There seems to be something wrong with this math.
If it’s argued that some of the bottom 21 states voted for the Democratic candidate, Hillary Clinton, then if we skip those states and count just Republican states the number diminishes a little but the same problem exists. The number of House votes will increase and there is still a large number of Senate votes. No matter how this is added up it is totally unfair. The smaller states each have two Senators and the number adds substantially to the number of electors representing them while the much larger states only have two senators.
The reason for the Electoral College may have made sense in the late 17 hundreds but it makes no sense today. A fair election in a Democracy is an election where all the people are equally represented. This does not exist with the Electoral College. It is past time for a change.
Even Donald Trump has called the system unreasonable. With a fairer system Trump said he would have done most of his campaigning in the bigger states. He believes he still would have won.
In addition, under the current system, there are actually 50 plus elections going on with no carry-over from one to the other. Forty-eight of the states are winner take all states. This means that every vote for the losing candidate is lost. In a truly democratic election there would still be one winner, but every single vote would matter until the winner was chosen. That doesn’t happen here. Hillary Clinton had well over two million more votes in the 2016 Election than Donald Trump.
In addition states like California send millions of tax dollars to the Federal Government. The smaller states are generally the recipients of much of this money since many of them receive much of this tax money in aid.
Trump ran up large margins in small cities and rural areas turning out white, working class workers in states like Michigan, Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, and Ohio. He also did extremely well in rural areas of battleground states like Florida and North Carolina, which he won.
It is certainly time to modernize our election system. All votes should be counted equally. The Founding Fathers did not visualize or necessarily approve of political parties. They developed a system that they believed would allow the President to be chosen by the best educated people living in the country. They never even had a glimmer of a country such as exists today.
Political Parties came into existence almost immediately after the Constitution was ratified. Alexander Hamilton organized the first political party, the Federalist Party. Shortly thereafter Thomas Jefferson organized the Democratic-Republican Party. Both men served under President George Washington.
We are now in the 21st Century. It is time to modernize the Constitution. Hillary Clinton should have won the 2016 Presidential Election. Hopefully Trump will not take us back to the 1920s and the disaster that followed in 1929.
Hillary Clinton had 2.8 million more votes than Donald Trump. She had approximately the same number as Barack Obama had in 2012. She won big in the larger states like California and New York, beating Trump by almost 2 for 1 in California. Trump, where he won, won by small margins. In the smaller states he won by slight margins; and mostly by votes in the underrepresented rural areas of the smaller states. It was an election where the smaller states, those that generally get economic help from the Federal Government, made Trump the winner. The 2016 Presidential Election was a prime example of rule by the minority.